Multicultural Policy and the Population Crisis: weaving our way between fear and opportunity

SSWAHS Multicultural Health Service and Health Language Service with the NSW Refugee Health Service
“Walking the tightrope to good health”: a conference on Multiculturalism to promote cultural integrity in quality health care. 23 June 2010   Karitane at Carramarr.

What population crisis?

¡  Too many people

§  For the eco-system; energy use; water; urban crowding; traffic

§  Of the “wrong sort”, too old, too young, wrong colour, ethnicity, religion, skill-set

§  In the wrong place: cities not rural and regional

§  Causing conflict; anger and aggression

§  Generating pollution and land degradation

§  Too many non-White babies

What population crisis?

¡  Too few people

§  We’re getting older

§  Fewer workers supporting more retirees

§  Not enough carers either voluntary or paid

§  Not enough skills to do the jobs we need

§  Rural towns becoming shells, with people moving to regional and urban centres

§  Not enough babies being born

§  Not enough “White” babies being born

§  Too much international competition for the “best” immigrants

Multicultural Policy is…

¡  Governments seeing society as being made up of continuing cultural groups based on common origins, values, and practices

¡  How will this “mix” be managed?

§  Permissively?

§  Education?

§  Regulation?

§  Prohibition?

Possible policies

¡  Assimilation: adapting to and adopting majority values, beliefs and practices

¡  Integration: focus on life in majority society while retaining “private world” of heritage practices

¡  Cultural diversity: cultural groups sustained and operate in wide realm of culture including services, education, communication

¡  Separation: parallel (maybe hierarchy) worlds including economic, most politics etc.

Current policy proposals

¡  “The people of Australia” 10 proposals went to Australian Govt in April 2010 asking that:

¡  1. All governments endorse cultural diversity

¡  2. Permanent advisory body

¡  3.Antiracism strategy, national human rights campaign

¡  4. Australian education curriculum include focus on civics and languages

¡  5. Productivity commission should monitor government services

¡  6. Protocols (eg impact criteria on migrants/ cultural groups) on all policy proposals

¡  7. Better resourcing of English, training, settlement services

¡  8. Social Inclusion Agenda to include migrants and refugees

¡  9. Local resources to foster opportunities

¡  10. Encourage “overlapping” social participation.

What we* fear about population?

¡  Overwhelming numbers

¡  Too much “difference”

¡  Alien practices

¡  Personal threat

¡  Destruction of environment

¡  Too many strangers

¡  Collapse of community

¡  Isolation and loneliness

Rise of neo-Fascist organisations

Who are the “we” who fear?

What are the opportunities?

¡  Creative frictions

¡  New skills, experience, knowledge

¡  New communities

¡  Learning to manage diversity for productive and creative outcomes

¡  Channeling social behaviour towards sustainability through energy efficiency, economies of scale, cross-communal collaboration

¡  Drawing on different world views to solve shared problems

Continuing issues: where population meets policy

¡  Cultural maintenance and heritage values

¡  Gender relations

¡  Inter-generational conflict and communication

¡  Faith-based communities: freedom or constraint?

¡  Relations between communities, esp. with Indigenous

¡  Media stereotypes

¡  (from AHRC African Australians social inclusion project)

On the beach: selling Australia as a land and as a people

We often hear that Australia stands at a crossroads…. And most of the time whenever we need to take a major decision two different if unclear futures compete for our attention. Yet it‘s rarely the case that two government campaigns launched within weeks of each other so starkly frame different visions and representations of “the nation”.

Read more